The Former Prophets is often referred to as the Deuteronomistic History. These books have been edited by the Deuteronomist "to explain why the nation of Israel was destroyed by the Babylonians in the sixth century BCE. The story, he claims, focuses on the idolatry of Israel’s kings and people and explains why Yhwh allowed judgment to come upon them. Written to the Judean refugees of the Babylonian exile, the DH justified God and at least provided the assurance to the exiles that what happened happened for a reason" (Bandastra).
Our task this week is to look through some passages from the DtrH and "[s]ummarize what each passage says or implies about the relationship between a) faithfulness to Y*WH and [the] covenant, and b) the events of social and political history." I will be looking at the following passages:
Our task this week is to look through some passages from the DtrH and "[s]ummarize what each passage says or implies about the relationship between a) faithfulness to Y*WH and [the] covenant, and b) the events of social and political history." I will be looking at the following passages:
- Deuteronomy 28:1-68
- Joshua 23:1-16
- 1 Samuel 12:1-25
- 2 Kings 17:5-18
- 2 Chronicles 36:11-21
Deuteronomy 28:1-68
This passage was actually a little creepy. To be faithful to God you must follow all of the instructions given in the scroll of Deuteronomy. If you don’t carefully keep all the words of this Instruction that are written in this scroll, by fearing the awesome and glorious name of the Lord your God— the Lord will overwhelm you and your descendants with severe and chronic afflictions, and with terrible and untreatable sicknesses. (28:58-59)If the people of Israel did not follow the Instruction, they would become cannibals, sick, and live in a place where the sky and earth were metallic. If they followed every law, the people would be blessed beyond measure.
Now if you really obey the Lord your God’s voice, by carefully keeping all his commandments that I am giving you right now, then the Lord your God will set you high above all nations on earth. (28:1)This chapter was added by the Deuteronomist during the reign of Josiah as a way of convincing the people to conform to the reform. Josiah was centralizing the religious practices of the people back to Jerusalem by closing any of the rural altars. This chapter seems to scare the people from breaking any part of the covenant with YHWH.
Joshua 23:1-16
This passage serves as a warning for the people. The beloved Joshua is dying. He reminds the people to obey the instructions of the covenant and even sets out some specific reminders:
Carefully obey everything written in the Instruction scroll from Moses. Don’t deviate a bit from it either to the right or to the left. Don’t have anything to do with these nations that remain with you. Don’t invoke the names of their gods or take oaths by them. Don’t serve them or worship them. Hold on to the Lord your God instead, exactly as you’ve done right up to today... For your own sake, be very careful to love the Lord your God. But if you should turn away and join the rest of these nations that remain with you, intermarry with them, and associate with each other, then know for certain that the Lord your God won’t keep on removing these nations before you. Instead, they will be a snare and a trap for you. If you violate the covenant of the Lord your God, which he commanded you to keep, and go on to serve other gods and worship them, then the Lord will be furious with you. You will quickly vanish from the fertile land that he has given you. (6-8; 11-13; 16)Again we see the text offering rewards for proper rule following, and curses for the breaking of the commandments.
1 Samuel 12:1-25
This is Samuel's farewell speech. He warns the people about disobeying God and the king. To remain faithful people they must:
2 Kings 17:5-18
This is Samuel's farewell speech. He warns the people about disobeying God and the king. To remain faithful people they must:
If you will fear the Lord, worship him, obey him, and not rebel against theLord’s command, and if both you and the king who rules over you follow the Lord your God—all will be well. But if you don’t obey the Lord and rebel against the Lord’s command, then the Lord’s power will go against you and your king to destroy you. (14-15)I found it interesting that this passage specifically tells the people to listen to the king. Samuel, who was once very against the idea of a monarchy, is encouraging the people to obey the monarchy.
2 Kings 17:5-18
This passage chronicles the exile of the Israelites to Babylon. "And this occurred because the people of Israel had sinned against the Lord their God" by worshipping false gods, burning their children as offerings, and they abandoned the covenant. They had been unfaithful, and this resulted in their exile.
2 Chronicles 36:11-21
This passage of scripture again explains the exile. King Zedekiah ignored the prophet Jeremiah and rebelled against King Nebuchadnezzar, thus ignoring the messengers of God.
It seems there was a lot of fear mongering used throughout the political history of Israel. Mess up, break a rule, and you will be exiled (or turned into a zombie).
Time and time again, the Lord, the God of their ancestors, sent word to them through his messengers because he had compassion on his people and his dwelling. But they made fun of God’s messengers, treating God’s words with contempt and ridiculing God’s prophets to such an extent that there was no hope of warding off theLord’s rising anger against his people. So God brought the Babylonian king against them. The king killed their young men with the sword in their temple’s sanctuary, and showed no pity for young men or for virgins, for the old or for the feeble. (15-17)The monarchy had broken the covenant and that resulted in an exile. During the midst of reform, Josiah and the priests were "trying to following the covenant." If the monarchy and people do not, well, there will be another exile.
It seems there was a lot of fear mongering used throughout the political history of Israel. Mess up, break a rule, and you will be exiled (or turned into a zombie).
I always feel smarter after reading your blog!
ReplyDeleteIN conversations with students we often talk about the "pull yourself up by your bootstraps" mentallity and I try to help them see that not everyone has "bootstraps" and how do we live in a just society when not everyone starts out with the same resources? I think part of this mentality comes from mis-interpretation of the Old Testament texts like the ones you cited. When we consider the fear mongering used throughout the political history of Israel and the consistent passages that tell the people to shape up or God's judgement is upon them then, of course, we will bring this theology into our present day setting.
I wonder if we reconsidered the texts from this week as the historians way of explaining why horrible things were happening? There must be someone to blame, right? It's difficult for my post-enlightenment brain to consider how ancient people's understood the tragedies taking place. Of course the people must have done something wrong for cannibalism, devastation, and exile to occur? Oh wait, we still do this in modern culture every time a tv evangelist says "that hurricane in New Orleans was due to all of the homosexuals" or every time a well meaning person says "It's God's will that your child died" and other pithy sayings.
The one thing I will take away from this class is "what did the writer intend in telling this story?" This helps me to more fully understand the judgement, wrath, devastation, etc. that we are reading about and why it might be important for us today!
Lisa, I love where you are going here! It is the great paradox of our faith: a loving and Holy God who wants the best for us but allows bad things to happen. Why, why, why? The theology freaks me out here in our readings this week, but the heart of the Israelite's trying to figure out how to follow God's will to avoid bad things happening completely makes sense for the time in which they were living. I have great empathy for them as a people that I did not have before...
DeleteIn reading your post I see that you came away with some similar thougths as I did about the way God was presented in these passages. There is an awful lot of talk about rules and the consequences of breaking them. Honestly it didn't feel like there was much time spent on rewards for following rules. Did you have as hard of a time reconciling this image of God with the one that we learn of through Christ in our time? In many places I didn't recognize the God of these passages as my God at all. This week's material was particularly challenging for me.
ReplyDeleteThank you for this post.
Rules and rewards tends to be something that we still see a lot of in society. How often do we call getting a raise a blessing? Well obviously, we worked hard to get that raise, but why is it a blessing? Did God give us the blessing? I think that this mind set is so integrated into today's society. I really appreciated your post. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteThanks to your informative post, I also feel smarter after reading this! I had a hard time writing my post on this topic, but I love how you broke up the readings and attacked it one at a time. It was very easy to follow and understand. I also enjoyed your honesty saying how it was creepy and gross! These passages deal with why Israel suffered, but how can we use this lesson in today’s society? Jonathon brings up a great point/question. “Did God give us the blessing?” I wonder why we still continue to struggle with this.
ReplyDelete